Thu 20 Jul 2006
I’ve often been fascinated by the way your sense of direction works. By that I don’t mean knowing from landmarks where you are or being able to follow maps, I mean the sense, wherever you are, of knowing which direction is North, for no reason other than that North just ‘feels different’ from the other directions. I’m fairly sure it’s got something to do with some interaction between your brain and the Earth’s magnetic field. I’m fascinated with it partly for philosophical reasons and partly because I’m curious about the ways it can go wrong.
The philosphical stuff first. I didn’t think anything of that kind of sense of direction until about 10 years ago I casually remarked on the topic to one of my then housemates. To my amazement, she didn’t know what I was talking about: She simply didn’t have the same sense (The series of conversations that followed temporarily earned me the nickname ‘magnetic man’ amongst that particular social circle). Following up with a couple of her friends revealed the same thing. It appears that what I thought of as perfectly normal and unremarkable, actually isn’t shared by a significant portion of the population. That gets me wondering, how do you describe the sensation. I simply can’t. I know that North ‘feels different’ to any other direction (to be pedantic, that’s probably not quite right, it’s probably more like that each direction feels different, but I’m so used to mentally using North as a reference direction). But beyond that, words fail me, literally. I have nothing else I can compare the sensation to. It’s a little bit like the problem of, ‘how do you explain to a blind man what it’s like to see, or to a deaf man what it’s like to hear?’ I quite often ponder the question, but never find an answer. Consideration of those kinds of question that are the reason why I take a fairly spiritual view of the nature of the Universe, on the assumption that there is something pretty profound about consciousness itself, and that no explanation of life that is founded on materialism is ever going to suffice.
But when my sense of direction fails is I think equally fascinating, if a little more mundane. The most common case where it fails is if I’m on a street or in a building that faces any ‘diagonal’ direction (eg. NW, or NE, etc.). Then, almost invariably, the side that is nearest to North feels like it actually is North. I can only guess that somewhere in my brain’s processing, the dominent orientation of the available boundaries gets factored in, and my brain tries to make these run along the nearest available rectangular direction.
There’s also specific locations where it fails. Occasionally my sense of direction just disappears, but more usually it gives wrong results. Annoyingly, the Apress offices are one such location. Whenever I’m in the building, my sense of direction seems to rotate by 90 degrees anti-clockwise, so that what is East feels like North. It is just wierd. The building is on the West side of 9th Street, Berkeley (California), a street that runs North-South (actually that’s not quite right, the direction is a few degrees (I’d guess perhaps 10ish) towards NW-SE, but North-South is a pretty good approximation). (It’s between Parker and Dwight if anyone feels inclined to look it up on google maps
). That means that when I walk in the main entrance to the building, I’m walking, roughly, West. And that’s fine. It feels, correctly, like West. I go up the stairs, along the corridor, and get to my desk, and it’s goes wrong. Every time. I’m sitting at that desk at this very moment. I know perfectly well I’m facing East (OK, 10ish degrees North of East), looking towards 9th Street. Yet my sense of direction is firmly telling me that I’m facing North. Yet within a few seconds of leaving the building, I know my sense of direction will have righted itself.
Of course I’m pretty sure the explanation is pretty mundane. I’d hazard a guess there’s some steel bars running through the building (actually I don’t need to guess that much, some of them are visible). And I’d guess they have a chance magnetic field that is interfering with the Earth’s magnetic field inside the building. (At some point I really ought to buy a compass and bring it in to test that hypothesis). But the experience is anything but mundane - it’s fascinating, and very strange. Several times, I’ve tried to walk in, while concentrating to see if I can observe the point at which my sense of direction screws up, to see if I can experience my sense of direction changing, but no matter how many times I try, I can’t. I lose concentration, the moment misses me, and I end up once again, sitting in an office with my sense of direction giving me totally false information.
I’d love to know if anyone else has similar experiences?
For the sake of listing them, a few other places that similarly fool my sense of direction are: Underground trains (the BART under San Francisco is particularly bad here - a couple of times I’ve ended up exiting the BART at a station I’ve never been to before, and proceeded to walk exactly the wrong way along the road, until a few minutes later I started to notice something odd about which direction felt like which, presumably as my sense of direction starts to right itself). Flying back from the US to the UK - often feels like the plane is going West (but flying UK-US is fine). And the Convention Center in Los Angeles (where the last couple of PDC’s have been held) gives me the same 90-degree rotation that the Apress offices do.
October 10th, 2006 at 10:08 pm
I have those weird feelings too. One time my friends and I were walking around a city, and they both thought one way was North, and I was getting annoyed because I knew a different way was. That’s when I noticed it. I also have the problem with diagonal streets and buildings. My dad says he doesn’t have this sense, but my grandpa does. Maybe it’s genetic?
October 19th, 2006 at 1:37 am
First I have to say that I have absolutely no sense of direction, unless I’ve been to a place often enough to know how its oriented but beyond that its non-existant. Second, I study in New York City (so practically live there) and I still can’t develop any sense of direction at all, it’s been three years. But knowing that, everytime I travel on the subway to a different portion of the city I’m not that familiar with I get so disoriented after coming out the station, its unbelievable really. Yes they have signs pointing to the direction the streets are (such as NW corner of 42nd St, for example) but that information is useless for me. I would tend to take that information and work off of it but I end up going completely the wrong way and it happens everytime. So everytime I’m traveling with someone I let them lead the way and pose no questions about it.
Though for some reason when I recently traveled to London in the summer, my first time, I was able to find my way quite easily and rarely did I get lost. Its the strangest thing though, the whole time I was there I couldn’t orient myself N,S,E,W at all but I still found my way around. Odd?
November 20th, 2006 at 4:24 pm
@Tennisblazer1: English towns, like London, have a very different, and less regular arrangement of roads from the usual criss-cross completely-straight-road pattern characteristic of American towns. That tends to make navigation in the UK different since you have things like curves in the roads etc. to guide you (I find it easier but then I’m from the UK and so used to it). Could that be why you found navigation easier in London? Also, my limited experience (my only significant time in the US is in the Bay Area) I’d say direction signposts tend to be a lot more frequent in the UK.
December 4th, 2006 at 8:35 pm
Simon Robinson,
Although it seems to be easier to get around in NYC because its a city built on a grid system and that’s fairly a simple system to adapt to, its impossible for me. Like I said there are signs and directional posts on streets etc. but it has totally the opposite effect for me. Yet when I was in London (by the way magnificent country and city)even though the streets had curves and winding roads there was something about them that enabled me to navigate quite easily, providing that the directional signage found on the roads both in London and in NYC are equally disperse(in my opinion) . That was one of the most fascinating things I noticed while on holiday. I’m sure that being from the UK adapting to the U.S. system of navigation while visiting the Bay area was short of familiar, I suppose?
All I have to say is that I couldn’t believe how incredibly easy it was to navigate my way around above and underground in London. If you ever plan to visit NYC one day, I advise you to get a really good subway map and spare a couple of hours in case of confusion(it will happen). After 3 years I still carry a map with me, not that it does me any good.
March 10th, 2007 at 9:03 pm
Sir,
I seem to have the same sense of direction as you do. I am 14 years old this year and my mother told me to definitely post a reply to this website. She thinks it is very interesting and so do I.
This “sense” I have is hard to explain. Whenever I face a direction it “looks” or “feels” like that direction. Like you said, it fails at certain times, and every instance I can think of it flips 90 counterclockwise: east becomes north, north becomes west, west becomes south, and south becomes east. It starts in certain places and then stops. I try to concentrate on it being the right directions but then lose the concentration and it falls back into the wrong place.
I am particular (maybe a bit eccentric) about which direction light comes from. For example, I do not like sunlight from the east very much, or indoor light dominating from the north. because I don’t like the “feel.” This can be frustrating at times. I remember being about 3 years old and having particular directions I liked and disliked.
I think you can relate to what this is like? Also, at diagonal streets, the NW, SE, NE, or SW automatically flip to N,E,S,and W.
It was interesting and enlightening to discover that someone else has these perceptions. I have asked my mother if she has this perception of directions and she didn’t really know what I was talking about. It is very hard to describe, because when you face a particular direction it is more of a “feel” than look.
At least there are some intelligent people such as yourself left on the Internet!
July 12th, 2007 at 7:10 pm
My sons tell me that men have better sense of direction because they have more iron in their bodies than women…could this be true? If one took more iron pills, could they gain a better sense of direction?
August 29th, 2007 at 4:27 pm
hi, I live in a small town (8,000 people) in Maine, USA, and I can barely travel out of my town. I can get lost in someone’s house unless I’m very careful to notice landmarks (such as a certain picture on the wall) or the fact that I turned left or right before I went into the bathroom.
I’m 44 years old and I’m close to giving up on this. I’ve been trying all my life to overcome this and I think I’ve finally resigned myself–until there’s a cure.
January 5th, 2008 at 7:19 am
I am from the southern hemisphere, and now live in the northern hemisphere.
When I moved here my normally good sense of direction was completely backwards! This was very confusing especially when coming up from the underground in London. I also have found that when you get to a new place and think one direction is north, it is very difficult to change this perception even if you know where north is.
I have recently bought a compass to verify where I think north is which has been very helpful especially at new tube stops.
March 8th, 2008 at 6:10 pm
I have heard that the difference between men and women’s sense of direction is, as someone already said, due to iron content, but, more specifically, that men have a large build-up of iron in the tips of their nose which helps them to sense direction better. I stumbled across this site looking for confirmation of that very fact. I am amazed, like some other people who have posted comments, to find so many similarities in myself to what you describe in your article. There are certain locations where my sense of direction is just completely wrong … and while I’ve never paid enough attention to be able to cite a specific example, I too feel like when I am on a diagonal street or in a diagonally-alligned building, I just sense the closest thing to north as north (as well as the rest) …
While this article didn’t answer my original question, it has certainly brought up many more …
I will bookmark this page and try to report back anything I find in my researching …
Rob